Simply Dumb

The powers that be in Jarkarta, Indonesia have come up with a novel way to solve the issue of readily apparent widespread poverty within their city limits.  They haven’t instituted a program encouraging full employment, they haven’t opened new soup kitchens, and they haven’t simply banned panhandling. 

Instead, they’ve made it a crime punishable by up to six months in jail or $5000 in fines!  I can’t imagine these people are able to make nearly that much in a year, let alone in a few days.  The logical extension, Indonesia appears out to send all it’s poor people to jail. 

My question is, after they’ve carted all these buskers off to the slammer, how many of Jakarta’s 10 million citizens will remain?

The Indonesian authorities have approved a new law banning people from giving money to buskers, beggars and hawkers in Jakarta.

Offenders could face up to six months in jail and $5,000 (£2,500) fines.

Jakarta’s outgoing Governor Sutiyoso urged residents to follow the new rules, saying they would bring order to the city of 10 million people.

But critics fear the new laws are ill thought out, with little understanding about the realities of the city’s poor.

The new law – which replaces a 19-year-old bylaw – are expected to come into force later this week.

Sprawling city

As well as banning donations to beggars and buskers, the new law regulates other aspects of public order.

This ranges from banning squatter settlements on river banks and highways, to spitting and smoking on public transportation. Unauthorised people cleaning car windscreens and managing traffic at busy intersections will also be penalised.

"This is to put order into things of common interest," Governor Sutiyoso told reporters.

One city politician said Jakarta should aim to emulate nearby Singapore, which strictly enforces public order regulations.

But critics fear it will be a difficult law to enforce in such a sprawling and congested city, which has seen an influx of poor migrants from the countryside.

Some politicians urged the government to allow time for the public to learn about the new rules.

source Tags: dumb news, panhandling, beggers, indonesia, jakarta, fine, arrest, jail

Comments Off